Nearly nine years ago, in November 2017, I faced criminal charges for joining a protest against the visit of then U.S. President Donald Trump to the Philippines. He was in Manila for the 31st ASEAN Summit hosted by then President Rodrigo Duterte. What should have been an exercise of our constitutional right to protest ended in a violent police dispersal.
Water cannons, truncheons and even a sonic weapon were used against protesters trying to march toward the summit venues. I was among the progressive lawmakers and protest leaders charged with violating the Public Assembly Act, direct assault and disobedience to persons in authority. The police accused us of inciting protesters to breach barricades.
I considered the charges politically motivated, particularly since I was a sitting member of Congress exercising my right to dissent against a visiting foreign leader. The assault and disobedience charges were eventually dropped for lack of evidence that we had personally attacked police officers.
That experience exposed a familiar contradiction: government readily invokes democracy and national sovereignty in dealing with foreign powers but becomes intolerant when Filipinos exercise those same rights to question our relationship with a powerful ally.
Trump is back in Manila, nearly nine (9) years later. His return brings into focus issues far bigger than the visit itself: military access, economic dependence, geopolitical rivalry, climate responsibility and Philippine sovereignty.
Two international conferences in distant venues provide a useful lens through which to examine these issues: COP31 in Antalya, Türkiye, and the 49th ASEAN Summit in Manila.
Their agendas differ, but both reveal the unilateralist character of Trump’s foreign policy—one that puts American strategic and economic interests ahead of multilateral commitments and the concerns of less powerful nations.
America’s retreat from climate responsibility
While Trump is welcomed in Manila, the United States is drawing criticism in Türkiye for its absence from international climate negotiations. For the second consecutive year, his administration has declined to send an official government delegation to the UN climate conference.
Trump has dismissed climate change as a hoax while his government retreats from international commitments and rolls back domestic environmental protections.
This is no minor diplomatic snub. The United States is among the world’s largest historical contributors to greenhouse gas emissions and possesses enormous economic and technological resources.
Its withdrawal weakens efforts to secure climate finance, adaptation support and compensation for loss and damage—commitments particularly vital to developing countries that have contributed little to the crisis but suffer its worst consequences.
Washington’s retreat also creates space for China and other powers to present themselves as defenders of multilateral cooperation. But for countries like the Philippines, the issue is not which superpower fills the diplomatic vacuum. It is whether the international community will deliver the resources and concrete commitments needed to confront a crisis already devastating vulnerable communities.
Trump’s return: Military dependence and strategic alignment
The concerns raised in Türkiye are not disconnected from what is happening in Manila. Opposition to Trump’s visit has brought together progressive lawmakers, church groups, people’s organizations, farmers, workers, Indigenous communities, professionals and student activists.
Their protest is directed not simply at Trump but at the policies and agreements associated with his administration and the Marcos government’s unquestioning alignment with Washington.
The Makabayan bloc has filed House Resolution No. 1593 opposing the administration’s reception of Trump. At the heart of the protest is the concern that the Philippines continues to grant Washington military and diplomatic concessions without adequately examining what the country gives up in return.
The expansion of American military access under the Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement (EDCA), additional military sites and increasingly frequent joint exercises risks drawing the Philippines deeper into the strategic confrontation between Washington and Beijing.
We have every right to defend our territorial integrity and maritime interests in the West Philippine Sea. But defending these rights should not mean surrendering our independence in determining our security and foreign policy. An expanded US military presence does not automatically guarantee Philippine security. It could just as easily make our territory a staging ground for a wider conflict, exposing our people to dangers over which we have little control.
The question is not whether we should maintain relations with the United States, but whether these relations genuinely serve Philippine sovereignty and the Filipino people.
Pax Silica: Development for whom?
Beyond military cooperation, Trump’s visit brings another major concern: Philippine participation in Pax Silica, a US-led initiative to build allied supply chains for critical minerals, semiconductors, artificial intelligence infrastructure and advanced manufacturing.
The Marcos administration promotes it as an opportunity to attract billions in investments, create jobs and move the country up the global value chain. But the projected economic gains must be weighed against the social and environmental costs.
The proposed industrial hub in New Clark City raises serious questions about the allocation of land, ancestral domains and agricultural communities.
Aeta communities in Tarlac and farmers whose land claims may not be adequately reflected in formal titles deserve particular attention. Experience has shown how large development projects can displace communities that have occupied and cultivated their land for generations. Promised investments and jobs may come later; the loss of land and livelihood can be immediate and irreversible.
The environmental costs also deserve scrutiny. Semiconductor manufacturing and critical mineral processing require enormous amounts of water and electricity, potentially placing additional pressure on the Sacobia watershed and encouraging destructive mining elsewhere.
More fundamentally, will Pax Silica strengthen domestic industries, build technological capabilities and provide decent jobs? Or will it primarily give foreign corporations access to our land, resources and cheap labor while technology, intellectual property and profits remain in foreign hands?
The same questions apply to the Luzon Economic Corridor and related infrastructure initiatives. Our opposition is not to development or foreign investment. It is to a development model that sacrifices land rights, food security, environmental protection and economic independence for promises whose benefits may largely accrue to foreign corporations.
Sovereignty must come before alignment
What connects the conferences in Türkiye and Manila is the same fundamental question about American power. In one, Washington retreats from its responsibility in addressing a global crisis to which it has contributed enormously. In the other, it expects allies to accommodate its military and economic priorities while reserving the freedom to act unilaterally.
For the Philippines, this is not an abstract debate. It concerns access to our territory, control over our natural resources, the direction of our economic development and our ability to chart an independent course amid intensifying geopolitical rivalries.
This does not mean rejecting bilateral cooperation. Relations between nations must rest on mutual respect, not unquestioning obedience. The Marcos administration must answer – must be be made accountable – for the military access it grants, the economic commitments it enters into and the communities that may bear their costs. A high-level summit cannot place these decisions beyond public scrutiny.
Nearly nine years ago, I faced criminal charges for protesting the visit of an American president.
Today, the same struggle for democratic rights and national independence confronts us in a different form.
Whether the issue is climate responsibility in Türkiye or military and economic cooperation in Manila, we must ask whose interests our government is really serving.
Our foreign policy and development priorities should be measured not by how closely they advance Washington’s geopolitical and corporate agenda, but by how well they protect our people, resources and future.
National sovereignty and peoples’ interest trump Pax Silica! (davaotoday.com)
